GE2 - Second German Edition


Publisher: Breitkopf & Härtel
Date: ca 1851-1852
Plate number: 5707
Title: Deux Polonaises || Polonaise I
Dedication: son ami J. Dessauer

The second German edition, in which the text of GE1 was subject to a quite detailed review. The most striking errors of GE1 were corrected, i.a.:

  • the incorrect tenth in bar 5 was corrected
  • the overlooked staccato dots were added (bars 313-1784-85)
  • a quaver stem was added in bar 12
  • the pedal's release sign was added in bar 20
  • a slur in bar 37 was added
  • a short accent was added in bar 44
  • a note in the L.H. in bar 75 was removed
  • erroneous ligatures in bar 77 were removed
  • the sign of a reversed accent in bar 79 was corrected
  • rests and fermatas in bar 83 were added

In addition, the revisers introduced a number of arbitrary changes:

  • the  indication was changed to  in the entire Polonaise
  • the length of the hairpins was revised (they were often extended for an entire bar)
  • range of slurs was changed (e.g., bars 73224-2784-85)
  • some of the notes were combined with a common stem in bars 23-27
  • staccato dots were added for the 2nd chord in bar 3, in turn, others were removed in bar 38
  • a slur was added in bar 40 (correct revision)
  • rests were added in the bottom voice in bar 40
  • all quavers were combined with one beam in bar 43
  • accidentals in bar 69 were added

The edition includes a few new mistakes, out of which the most significant are the oversight of a stem in bar 19 and deletion of hairpins in bar 38.

The numerous entries written in pencil visible in the presented copy are of no source value.

Original in: The Fryderyk Chopin Institute Library, Warsaw
Shelf-mark: 1656/n