|
Spelling in sources |
|
|
Spelling suggested by the editors |
The authentic chromatic notation of the descending part of the roulade takes into account the validity of the previously entered accidentals only to a minimal extent:
- In a few places Chopin chose enharmonic variants requiring a greater number of accidentals than necessary – c
4 as the 15th note, b
3 (18th), g3 (25th), f3 (29th), e3 (33rd), c3 (39th), b2 (43rd). As in such a chromatic sequence enharmonic variants of notation practically do not impact the understanding of music, we exceptionally change this orthography in the main text to avoid excessive complications. It allows us to reduce the number of accidentals on the 2nd, 3rd and 4th beats of the bar by 8 (in the authentic notation we also count the 3 accidentals overlooked by Chopin – see below). - Assuming a regular structure of the figuration – which is almost impossible to challenge – Chopin overlooked a
cancelling an alteration that has occurred earlier in the bar three times – no naturals to c4 (14th note), a3 (20th note) and f3 (31st note). - The
to g3 was unnecessarily repeated (22nd note).
This notation was repeated without any changes by the majority of the editions. Only in FESB a restoring c4 was added (14th note).
Compare the passage in the sources »
category imprint: Interpretations within context; Differences between sources; Editorial revisions
issues: Omissions to cancel alteration, FE revisions, Errors repeated in GE, Errors repeated in FE, Errors repeated in EE
notation: Pitch