Crotchet b & quaver a in CJ |
||
Quavers b & g in CB, contextual interpretation |
||
Crotchet b in EL |
||
Crotchet b & quaver a suggested by the editors |
Extending the b quaver to a crotchet, which results in a g(a)-b third at the end of the bar, is probably a specification of notation introduced in [A2]. The additional stem is absent in CK (→CB), whereas in EL this note is a crotchet, since the last quaver was omitted. It is almost certainly Kolberg's revision, suggesting his knowledge of the authentic notation of [A2], although it had not been reproduced in CK – he could have considered the additional stem to be a correction of the text of the last beat of the bar. The aforementioned third leads to a-c1 in the next bar, which is slightly obscured by the Chopinesque simplified orthography (in CB the last quaver is written as g; however, the raising b to b in the penultimate one was overlooked). In the main text we add a cautionary to the Chopinesque a.
Compare the passage in the sources »
category imprint: Interpretations within context; Differences between sources; Editorial revisions; Corrections & alterations
issues: Kolberg's revisions, Balakirev's revisions
notation: Rhythm