The authenticity of the b note's hold is undoubtedly certified only in Ap and only in this bar, as in analogous bars 12 and 39 there are no ties. The authenticity of the version with the repeated b note on the 3rd beat of the bar is much better certified:
- in CLI the hold was not marked in any of three places (bars 4, 12 and 39);
- the ties are also absent in the base text for FE, which is proved by their lack in FEcor, Chopin did not add them despite several stages of corrections of the edition's production. At the same time, we cannot talk about a possible oversight of this detail, as in one of the later proofreadings the composer added phrase marks combining f-e in the lower voice in all three places.
Hence the ties included in GE are most probably a revision. The first (and also subsequent) editors of Chopin's works would often, at their own discretion, add the allegedly missing ties in the places where only a part of the two-note chords' or chords' components were really sustained.
To the main text we adopt the undoubtedly authentic version of FE (→EE2→EE3).
Compare the passage in the sources »
category imprint: Differences between sources
issues: EE revisions, GE revisions
notation: Rhythm